13 Comments
User's avatar
Summer Noel's avatar

Wow, I love this so so much! My jaw literally dropped when I read that they they felt the show had “too much” of a female perspective when it literally has a female lead... it’s so sad that women’s stories (that are actually from their perspective) continue to be put aside in favor of capitalizing off them and their suffering.

Truly appreciate your commentary on this! Everything you explained is exactly why I’ve been unable to bring myself to watch Euphoria no matter how much I’m told to watch it. Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment
Madison Huizinga's avatar

I’m so glad this resonated with you! I’ve felt the same way about Euphoria, often feels like I’m the only one that takes issues with the show’s writing. Glad to read about more people viewing Levinson’s work through a more critical lens.

Expand full comment
maria luisa's avatar

The ripple effect I fear the most is the further glamorization of mental illness in young girls as an aesthetic (i.e. “in my fleabag era”) instead of extending compassion to the people this show is clearly taking inspiration from and re-examining the damage that’s been made.

Expand full comment
Madison Huizinga's avatar

Exactly, you’ve hit the nail on the head. I often think about how Tumblr culture of the 2010s contributed to the aestheticization of mental illness too, The Idol is just the latest interpretation of that aesthetic.

Expand full comment
maria luisa's avatar

It’s a repackaging of that for the TikTok era, exactly!

Expand full comment
Karl Straub's avatar

I liked the Black Swan film, but I think you’re onto something very important here.

Expand full comment
Madison Huizinga's avatar

I enjoyed that movie as well! I do think the trope I’m referring to is prominent in that, but is also utilized in a more subversive manner at times.

Expand full comment
Karl Straub's avatar

I like that analysis! It does seem that some artists use tropes creatively to comment on toxic cultural norms, while others just exploit them to draw paying customers. I’m not sure I’m always good at telling the difference, but that’s where commentators like you are so valuable.

Expand full comment
mel's avatar

The Idol only came on my radar last week and I didn't know what to make of its hype as I hadn't watched the trailer. Your take on the storyline has made me think twice about starting it and if I do end up watching this show I will definitely be watching out for if and when the plot exploits suffering women / glamourises destructive behaviours. Thank you for this insightful piece.

Expand full comment
Madison Huizinga's avatar

Thank you for reading! At the end of the day, this is all speculation based on Levinson’s previous work, reviews, and what I’ve seen in the trailer. I don’t have the stomach for The Idol (I couldn’t sit through Euphoria in its entirety), even under critical watch, but I’d be interested to know your thoughts if you do watch it!

Expand full comment
Deb's avatar

Really great examples of how society needs more compassion and that women more often than not still do not get to tell their own story .

Expand full comment
Sayani Sarkar's avatar

What did I watch last night? Where does art end and fetishization begin? Thanks so much for this commentary.

Expand full comment
Madison Huizinga's avatar

I’m glad to hear this resonated with you Sayani, and also happy to see many viewers are feeling similarly. This type of work shouldn’t be incentivized to be made! Thank you for reading!

Expand full comment